A good trade?

The problem is your thin at catcher even to start. Posada had an amazing year last year and he probably is not going to repeat his preformance. He is getting up their in age, and his numbers will probably return to normal. With a backup in varitek, not the strongest hitter either. The trade i think would be a good deal, if you had another back up catcher. If you can maybe work another deal, getting and giving someone else so you recieve a catcher, this deal would be good. Good luck!